Pin
This classic Italian Muffuletta sandwich delivers layers of savory meats and cheeses all brought together by a punchy marinated olive salad. It is beloved for its bold flavors and sheer abundance—a centerpiece at picnics and perfect for parties. Over the years, I have served this dense sandwich at family reunions and it never survives longer than an hour on the table.
The first time I made this was for a family tailgate and the sandwich disappeared before halftime. Now it is my signature for potlucks.
Ingredients
- Green olives: Bold briny kick look for firm pitted ones
- Black olives: Slightly milder earthiness high quality or kalamata can be wonderful
- Giardiniera: Adds crunch and tang look for crisp colorful pieces
- Roasted red peppers: Smoky sweetness pick bright red peppers for best color
- Capers: Salty pop soak or rinse to remove excess brine when needed
- Celery: Freshness and extra crunch go for crisp stalks with no wilt
- Garlic: Rich undertone mince finely for even distribution
- Extra virgin olive oil: Carries flavor and moisture choose cold-pressed for the fullest taste
- Red wine vinegar: A zesty acid note use a reputable brand for clean taste
- Dried oregano: Herbaceous backbone choose organic if possible
- Red pepper flakes: Subtle heat optional adjust for your spice tolerance
- Freshly ground black pepper: Sharpens all the flavors grind just before using
- Italian sesame seed bread: Classic structure and nutty finish look for a fresh rounded loaf
- Mortadella: Buttery smooth base choose fresh-sliced deli meat when you can
- Salami: Peppery and tangy a traditional must-have go for thin slices
- Capicola: Spiced pork with a hint of heat check for deep red marbling
- Provolone: Tangy and creamy opt for aged slices for more depth
- Mozzarella: Gentle creaminess use low-moisture for good layering
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Olive Salad:
- Combine the chopped green and black olives giardiniera roasted red peppers capers celery and minced garlic in a large bowl. Add the olive oil red wine vinegar dried oregano and red pepper flakes. Finish with black pepper to taste. Mix until everything is evenly coated. Cover tightly and refrigerate for at least one hour so the flavors blend thoroughly overnight is even better for an authentic taste.
- Prepare the Bread:
- Take your round loaf and cut it horizontally. If your loaf is very tall or dense gently remove a bit of the soft inside from each half this helps the fillings fit together snugly without bursting.
- Assemble the Layers:
- Start by spreading half the olive salad over the base layer of bread making sure to get an even layer to every edge. Arrange slices of mortadella followed by the salami capicola provolone and mozzarella in overlapping layers. Spoon on the rest of your olive salad for a bright punch.
- Press and Set:
- Place the top bread half over your sandwich and gently press down with your hands to begin compacting it. Wrap the whole sandwich tightly in plastic wrap and place it under a heavy skillet baking dish or similar weight. Allow it to press for at least thirty minutes. This step makes an enormous difference in flavor and structure.
- Slice and Serve:
- Unwrap your sandwich and use a sharp serrated knife to slice it into thick wedges or squares. Serve on a platter for a show-stopping centerpiece. The sandwich can also be refrigerated for a bit before slicing to help it hold together better for parties or picnics.
Pin
My favorite part of this sandwich is the bright layered olive salad it is loaded with so much flavor it easily steals the show. I remember making a double batch once and my uncle ate the salad straight from the bowl with a spoon before I even had time to assemble.
Storage tips
This sandwich keeps beautifully wrapped tightly in the fridge for up to thirty six hours. For best texture avoid freezing once assembled since the olive oil and bread can become soggy after thawing. Keep the olive salad separate if you want to meal prep several sandwiches throughout the week.
Ingredient substitutions
You can swap any of the listed meats try turkey or peppered ham for a milder flavor. If capicola is hard to find prosciutto or even roast beef can work. For cheese lovers go heavier on provolone. The olive salad can be tweaked with different pickled veggies such as artichoke hearts or pepperoncini for an extra bite.
Serving suggestions
Serve each sandwich slice with kettle chips and a crisp Italian salad for the perfect lunch. At parties I often serve smaller wedges as a hearty appetizer. For picnics wrap slices in wax paper and pack with napkins for easy transport.
A bit of history
Muffuletta traces back to Sicilian immigrants in New Orleans where this sandwich became a Creole-Italian staple. Traditionally served at the Central Grocery it is a satisfying example of cultural blending and Southern hospitality.
Recipe FAQs
- → What type of bread works best for muffuletta?
Traditional round Italian sesame bread offers the ideal texture and structure, but a sturdy crusty loaf can substitute if needed.
- → How far in advance can I make the olive salad?
Prepare the olive salad a day ahead for optimal flavor, allowing the ingredients to marinate and meld together overnight.
- → Is pressing the sandwich necessary?
Pressing compacts the layers and encourages the flavors to blend. Use a heavy pan or weighted object for best results.
- → Can I customize the meats and cheeses?
Absolutely! Swap in your favorite cured meats or cheeses to suit your preferences or what's available to you.
- → How should the sandwich be served?
Slice into wedges or generous squares and serve chilled or at room temperature. It's perfect for sharing at gatherings.